LEGISLATURE LOOKING AT LOGGING LAWS - Delegate Stemple Says More Enforcement Officers Needed

(01/07/2002)
Problems continue in West Virginia with loggers who refuse to follow "best practices" and ignore the law, according to the Coalition for Responsible Logging. Frank Slider of the West Virginia Sierra Club says "The voluntary enforcement of Best Management Practices is a miserable failure."

Some loggers contend they cannot make money if they abide by the statues, while others say that is not true. The State Division of Forestry says they could use another one million dollars and twenty more people to police the timber industry.

Delegate Bill Stemple, according to the Charleston Gazette, says "We just need more inspectors out there to help them. That would stop a lot of it." Lawmakers in Charleston are considering tightening timbering laws, and a legislative committee has been touring logging sites. Stemple is involved with an interim study looking at the 1992 logging act.

The issue is a touchy subject in Calhoun County, where relatives and neighbors make their living with logging. A recent trip across Cunningham Ridge discovered a Braxton County logger skidding logs down a county highway, blocking the road, and another operator working without a permit.

The Division of Forestry currently monitors about 1,300 logging licenses and 3,600 timber jobs a year. Much of the logging in Calhoun and Roane County is being done by out-of-area loggers, who get in and get out as quickly as they can, often ignoring reasonable practices, let alone the laws.

Some logging operations consistently overload trucks for hauling out of the county, a commonly accepted practice. Many local loggers do follow "best practices," but since there is no frost law in West Virginia, others destroy rural roads.

The West Virginia Department of Highways in Calhoun, Roane, Wirt and other counties attempt to prevent road destruction, but in some areas new blacktop and improved secondary roads have been "put down to the mud," according to a department spokesperson.

Highway officials contend the logging laws are so fragmented they are virtually impossible to enforce, with many different agencies having jurisdiction. In Calhoun and Wirt counties, the Department of Highways have made some efforts to collect money for rock to repair rural roads.

Connie Lewis, a lobbyist for the Coalition for Responsible Logging, says she would like to make it mandatory for loggers to follow best management practices, but Dick Waybright, executive director of the West Virginia Forestry Association, says adequate laws are in place.

The Coalition for Responsible Logging says if the laws are adequate, they have not been enforced.

Lewis says residents who have complained to her group say no action is taken against irresponsible loggers unless a complaint is filed, after which efforts are made for compliance.

A study was made regarding logging in Calhoun about one year ago, but a request to obtain the results from local forester Joe Taylor went unheeded, although the West Virginia Division of Forestry in Charleston has said they will make the report available.